Thursday, March 26, 2015

The First Clash

Finished reading The First Clash by Jim Lacey today, a history of the battle of Marathon. As the author notes early on, people know Thermopylae better lately because of the movie 300...and maybe because 300 vs. 300,000 is cooler than 10000 vs. 60000. (Rough numbers, all around - I don't feel the need to get exact about them, since for every one - except the 300 Spartans - nobody else seems 100% sure either.)

He makes the good point that, without Marathon, Thermopylae wouldn't have happened. Athens gets taken over, all the other city-states submit to Persia, Sparta holds out for a while... but the best case there is a glorious but decisive defeat. By showing that the Persians were not invincible - not by a long shot - the Greeks had some expectation that a battle held the possibility of victory.

This appears, of course, to be a Crisis period, at least for the Greeks. It's not clear whether Thermopylae 10 years later is the final culmination of the Crisis, or if it was a relatively minor issue
 to the Greeks, so indicating that this was more of a First Turning war than a Peak Crisis one.  At the least, though, Lacey refers to the men at Marathon as a "Greatest Generation" indicating that, whatever side of the Crisis they were on, those who were there were the Heroes of their day.

1 comment:

  1. Graton Casino & Resort, NV Jobs - Mapyro
    Graton Casino & Resort, Nevada, United States · Hotel: · 남원 출장샵 Reviews: 4.0 충청남도 출장안마 · Hotel Amenities: 여주 출장안마 · Free WiFi: · Free parking · Casino: · Sports Booking. 경상남도 출장샵 Rating: 3.9 나주 출장샵 · ‎2,406 reviews

    ReplyDelete